Resource mobilization theory is supplied in the study of social movements and argues the the success that social motions depends on resources (time, money, skills, etc.) and the capacity to usage them. As soon as the theory an initial appeared, it to be a breakthrough in the study of social movements because it focused on variables that room sociological rather than psychological. No longer were social activities viewed as irrational, emotion-driven, and disorganized. Because that the first time, impacts from exterior social movements, together as support from various organizations or the government, to be taken into account.

You are watching: Which of the following is not a criticism of resource mobilization theory?


According to resource mobilization theory, a an essential issue for social movements requires obtaining access to resources.The 5 categories of resources that institutions seek to obtain are material, human, social-organizational, cultural, and also moral.Sociologists have discovered that gift able to successfully utilize sources is attached to a social organization"s success.

The theory

In the 1960s and also 1970s, sociology researchers started to study how social motions depend on sources in order to bring about social change. When previous researches of social movements had looked at individual psychological factors that cause people to sign up with social causes, source mobilization concept took a broader perspective, looking in ~ the wider societal factors that enable social activities to succeed.


In 1977, john McCarthy and Mayer Zald published a key record outlining the concepts of source mobilization theory. In their paper, McCarthy and also Zald started by outlining terminology for their theory: society movement institutions (SMOs) are teams that support for social change, and also a society movement industry (SMI) is a collection of establishments which advocate for similar causes. (For example, elegance International and Human rights Watch would certainly each it is in SMOs in ~ the bigger SMI of human being rights organizations.) SMOs seek out adherents (people who support the objectives of the movement) and constituents (people that are affiliated in actually supporting a social movement; for example, through volunteering or donating money). McCarthy and also Zald additionally drew the distinction between civilization who was standing to directly advantage from a reason (whether or no they actually support the reason themselves) and people that don"t advantage from a cause personally however support it since they believe it is the best thing come do.


According to source mobilization theorists, there room several means that SMOs can acquire the sources they need: for example, society movements might produce sources themselves, accumulation the resources of your members, or seek out external sources (whether indigenous small-scale donors or bigger grants). According to resource mobilization theory, being able to properly utilize sources is a determinant of the success the a social movement. Additionally, source mobilization theorists look at how an organization"s resources affect its activities (for example, SMOs the receive resources from an external donor could potentially have their choices of tasks constrained through the donor"s preferences).


species of sources

According come sociologists who study resource mobilization, the types of resources required by society movements deserve to be grouped into 5 categories:


Material resources. These space the tangible sources (such together money, a ar for the organization to meet, and physical supplies) vital for an organization to run. Material resources can include anything from offers for making protest signs to the office structure where a huge nonprofit is headquartered.Human resources. This describes the labor needed (whether volunteer or paid) to conduct an organization"s activities. Depending upon the organization"s goals, specific species of an abilities may be particularly valuable form of person resources. For example, an company that looks for to increase accessibility to healthcare may have actually an especially great need for clinical professionals, if an organization focused on immigration regulation may look for out individuals with legal training come get affiliated in the cause.Social-organizational resources. These resources are ones the SMOs have the right to use to build their social networks. For example, one organization might develop an email list of civilization who support their cause; this would certainly be a social-organizational source that the organization could use itself and also share with various other SMOs the share the very same goals.Cultural resources. Cultural resources incorporate knowledge vital to command the organization"s activities. Because that example, knowing just how to lobby elected representatives, draft a policy paper, or organize a rally would certainly all be examples of social resources. Cultural resources can likewise include media commodities (for example, a publication or informational video clip about a topic pertained to the organization"s work).Moral resources. moral resources room those which assist the organization to be seen as legitimate. For example, celebrity endorsements have the right to serve together a kind of moral resource: once celebrities speak the end on instead of of a cause, people may be spurred to learn much more about the organization, see the organization much more positively, or even come to be adherents or ingredient of the company themselves.

instances

source Mobilization to aid People experiencing Homelessness

In a 1996 paper, Daniel Cress and David Snow conducted an detailed study that 15 institutions aimed at promoting the rights of civilization experiencing homelessness. In particular, they examined how the resources obtainable to each organization were linked to the organization"s success. They uncovered that access to sources was regarded an organization"s success, and also that details resources appeared to be particularly important: having a physical office location, gift able to attain necessary information, and also having efficient leadership.


Media Coverage because that Women's legal rights

Researcher Bernadette Barker-Plummer investigated exactly how resources allow organizations to gain media coverage of your work. Barker-Plummer looked at media coverage that the national Organization for females (NOW) indigenous 1966 until the 1980s and also found that the number of members NOW had actually was associated with the amount of media coverage now received in The new York Times. In other words, Barker-Plummer suggests, together NOW prospered as an organization and also developed more resources, that was additionally able to also gain media coverage because that its activities.

See more: Which Of The Following Best Summarizes American Economic Issues At The End Of The 1920S?


Criticism the the concept

While source mobilization theory has been one influential structure for understanding political mobilization, some sociologists have suggested that various other approaches are additionally necessary to totally understand society movements. Follow to Frances Fox Piven and also Richard Cloward, other components besides organizational resources (such as the experience of loved one deprivation) are vital for understanding social movements. Additionally, they emphasize the prestige of studying protests that occur exterior of formal SMOs.