One that my favourite MMO stories is exactly how I gained into Black Desert in the very first place. That was right after i tried out Final Fantasy XIV’s Eureka. I was excited for the video game mode yet was disappointed once I ultimately had a chance to play. I gave it for around three days, yet I wasn’t a vast fan of partying up and also grinding the boss monsters because that hours. (It in reality looks favor our FFXIV columnist Eliot also agreed through that sentiment.) despite my disappointment, I shortly realized this kind of grind was missing in mine life, therefore I began looking.

You are watching: Blade and soul or black desert online

Since I currently played “the big four,” I want a change of pace, so ns looked eastward: the domain the Blade & Soul, TERA, Black Desert, and ArcheAge. I initially settled on Blade & Soul and Black Desert, however in the finish my time (and money) saw Black Desert for 3 reasons: I want to be a dark knight, it had actually the nicer engine, and it to be a sandbox, a genre I never ever really tried.

I to be in an excellent company too. World often ask which of these two games is most worthy their time, offered that they’re among the larger and also newer and shinier oriental imports. So what far better opportunity than this particular day to take into consideration a deep, holistic, comparison between the 2 games? I plan on do this a two-part series. For today, we’ll simply cover the different architecture philosophies. And also as v my criticism the Black Desert’s RNG system, I’m no going to offer a “winner” per se, yet I’ll introduce the kind of player that might like this particular component.

In our team’s critical Overthinking article, ns alluded come the esoteric nature of these games. Only a particular kind that player will certainly play grind-centric titles. Yet if you’re the form of player that desires a adjust of speed from “the huge four,” they’re an excellent options. I’m likewise going to take numerous liberties: If you’re seriously considering picking in between these games, ns assuming you understand at the very least a little of what you’re obtaining yourself into. Whichever video game you choose, be ready to grind, invest money for a type of progress, and also endure lots of randomness.


Black Desert’s style philosophy

This game is a sandbox. There space very few instanced areas in this game, and also this game does not emphasis on merely grinding dungeons over and also over again. Players earn your levels and also money from grinding mobs, daily quests, and daily experience boosts. Players walk to their favorite grind spot and farm. New content typically comes in the form of much more grind spots and regions fairly than a set of brand-new dungeons. The dungeons Pearl Abyss does encompass are usually public dungeons too, yet they’re much more like underground grind spots much more than anything.

The game designs everything around this type of grinding, v biweekly events usually having actually some type of “kill monsters for this one-of-a-kind item” component. There’s open up PvP, of course, and also players are either intended to fight end the clues or relocate to one more server. Ns went into information on how servers functioned in my last article, but the brief version is that moving servers in this game is simple process. You can switch every 15 minutes, and there space a the majority of shards that the gameworld, so those who don’t want to PvP can at the very least leave.

A main tenet to this game’s design is the hope the you’ll never ever be logging out of the darn thing. There room myriad work that deserve to be done away from the keyboard. I’ve formerly covered BDO’s fishing system, yet there’s also setting up the worker empire, crafting, building boats, and horse training. Heck, human being can even grind level without actually being in front of the game.

Black Desert is probably best known for its graphics, therefore players in search of a important pretty video game should give this game a try. In a nod to west aesthetics, the video game has really made it a point to show off just how shiny armor can gain with critical year’s Remastered patch. Significant cities have a distinctive European look, and also those who took pleasure in an eastern interpretation of the west (akin to Dark Souls) will gain the setting.


Blade & Soul’s design philosophy

In contrast, Blade & Soul employs the unique wuxia style. Because that those not in the know, the wuxia period is to China what the medieval time period is come Europe. It’s essentially their fantasy genre. This game is for this reason colorful; animations develop a water-like smoothness to character movements. This to be much an ext unfamiliar are for me personally – no at every a negative thing! – and those searching for something that isn’t in a stereotypical western fantasy setting will enjoy the feel and look that this.

Insofar as exactly how it’s structured, B&S has much more in typical with a themepark choose World that Warcraft than v BDO, but it’s not precisely the same. There space instanced dungeons, yet they’re nowhere close to as long; in fact, several of the at an early stage dungeons I’ve to be to space pretty short. Lock only about two or three rooms big, so world might also think the a miniature story instance. The dungeons space much much more like FFXIV’s Heavensward raids with a small group the trash and also a significant boss battle in the end. This video game does have actually an amazing tower mode too that ns wish Black Desert had. (I’ll enter this in depth in the following article.) ns haven’t personally played lot of this mode, but it’s usually a tower because that one-on-one boss battles.

Players likewise need come be mindful that there are two control schemes because that this game. The very first is the quintessential action combat mode, whereby the video game controls prefer a third-person action game. The second is standard mode, which plays favor WoW with modifications to accommodate because that the activity combat. This is a huge thing for me because I play far better this way; together a devoted tank player, ns like maintaining my eyes open up to transforms in the battlefield.

See more: Richard " Rip Taggart Navy Seal, Six (Tv Series)

Overall, I’d say the Blade & Soul feels much much more familiar come the classic MMO player than Black Desert. This video game is a themepark MMO v the trinity. The tank, damage dealer, and also healer roles are present. Bosses have mechanics, so tells need to be dodged, mechanics should be handled, and DPS checks must be met. Black Desert is much lighter ~ above these varieties of mechanics, for this reason if you prefer tough, well-choreographed boss fights, walk for B&S. That’s why I’d say the Blade & Soul is much more for those who still want a acquainted experience in a different setting.


The architecture philosophy might be enough for part players to do a decision, yet there’s still so much much more to cover! sign up with me in my next write-up where I’ll analysis the combat system of every game and what they carry out with it! additionally please permit me know in the comments what you’d prefer me come look into for comparison’s sake – or if you want me to to compare Black Desert with another game!